Diminished Value Guide

Even a perfeclty repaired vehicle has diminished value

Diminished Value Guide

Even after your car is repaired, it may be worth less than it was before the accident. This is called diminished value. Many insurance companies underpay or avoid DV claims entirely. This guide helps you understand your rights and how much money you may be owed.

Common Diminished Value Questions

What is diminished value

Diminished value is the loss in your vehicle's market value after an accident, even after proper repairs. Buyers pay less for a car that was in a crash.

EstiVerify helps you calculate how much value your car lost and whether the insurer owes you for it.

Why does my car lose value even after good repairs

Accident history shows up on reports like Carfax. Buyers treat accident cars as less reliable and pay less. This is why diminished value exists.

EstiVerify estimates how much value your car loses because of the accident record.

Does every accident cause diminished value

Not always. Diminished value depends on the severity of the hit, the vehicle type, mileage, and age. Newer cars lose more value than older ones.

EstiVerify tells you if your car qualifies and how much you may be owed.

Does my insurance company pay diminished value

It depends on your state and whether you were at fault. Some insurers deny DV automatically unless you know how to request it.

EstiVerify helps you understand your rights based on your state and claim details.

Is diminished value real or just a negotiation tactic

Diminished value is real. Courts recognize it. Buyers recognize it. Insurance companies recognize it but often avoid paying unless challenged.

EstiVerify gives you clear numbers so you can pursue a valid DV claim confidently.

How do I know if my car qualifies for diminished value

Cars qualify for DV when the accident is on record and the repairs affect value. Newer, higher value vehicles qualify more often.

EstiVerify checks your year, make, model, mileage, and damage severity to determine eligibility.

Can older cars get diminished value

Older cars can receive DV, but the amount is usually lower because the base value is low. DV is higher on newer cars.

EstiVerify calculates DV for any qualifying vehicle so you know if it is worth pursuing.

Does high mileage affect my DV claim

Yes. High mileage reduces vehicle value, which can reduce diminished value as well. But it usually does not eliminate it entirely.

EstiVerify includes mileage adjustments so you get an accurate DV number.

Does DV apply if the repairs were perfect

Yes. Even perfect repairs cannot remove the accident from the vehicle history report. Buyers still value it less.

EstiVerify explains why your car still lost value and how much.

Can I get DV if I was at fault

Usually no. Diminished value is typically paid only when another driver was at fault. However, it varies by state and coverage.

EstiVerify helps you confirm whether your situation qualifies for DV.

How is diminished value calculated

DV is calculated by comparing your car's pre accident value to its value after repairs with the accident on record. Insurance often uses formulas that undervalue your claim.

EstiVerify checks the insurer's numbers and calculates a fair DV estimate.

Why is the insurance DV formula so low

Many insurance formulas cap DV at unrealistic percentages or use adjustments that reduce the payout unfairly.

EstiVerify explains where the insurer reduced the value and what the real number should be.

Why did they deduct so much for mileage

Mileage affects value, but insurance sometimes uses excessive deductions because most customers do not question it.

EstiVerify checks whether the depreciation is fair or inflated.

Why is DV higher on luxury or high value cars

Because buyers pay a premium for perfect condition on high value vehicles. Any accident history reduces their resale value more.

EstiVerify calculates DV based on the type of vehicle you own.

Does the repair cost affect diminished value

Yes. Larger repairs usually signal more serious damage, which increases diminished value. Insurance may try to downplay severity to reduce DV.

EstiVerify reviews your estimate to calculate DV more accurately than a generic formula.

Why does insurance deny DV claims so often

Because DV payouts cost money. Many insurers deny DV until you show evidence or challenge their reasoning.

EstiVerify provides documentation that strengthens your DV request.

Why do they say DV is already included in the repair payment

This is incorrect. Repair payments cover fixing the car. Diminished value covers the drop in market value after the repair.

EstiVerify helps you refute this common excuse with clear information.

Why did they offer such a low DV number

Insurance often starts with a low offer hoping you accept it without research. They use formulas designed to reduce the payout.

EstiVerify compares the offer to real DV calculations so you know how low it is.

Why do they avoid answering DV questions

Some adjusters are not trained in DV. Others know DV is valid but prefer to avoid the topic to reduce claims.

EstiVerify helps you ask the right questions so you get real answers.

Why do they ask for proof that my car lost value

They want documentation because DV claims vary widely. Without proof, they default to lower numbers.

EstiVerify gives you solid DV evidence you can send directly to the insurer.

Is diminished value allowed in every state

No. Some states allow DV claims, some limit them, and some restrict them entirely. Michigan, for example, does not recognize DV.

EstiVerify explains your DV rights based on your state.

How do state laws affect my DV claim

Your ability to claim DV depends on your location. Some states allow third party DV only. Others allow first party. A few states have no DV rights at all.

EstiVerify checks your state's DV rules before recommending next steps.

Can I claim DV if the accident was minor

Minor accidents can still reduce value if repairs show up on vehicle history reports. However, DV amounts vary based on severity.

EstiVerify helps you determine whether the loss is large enough to pursue.

Can I claim DV if the other driver had no insurance

It depends on your coverage. DV usually requires a third party at fault with liability insurance.EstiVerify helps you understand whether your situation qualifies under your policy.

Does DV apply if the repairs used OEM parts

Yes. Even perfect OEM repairs cannot remove the accident record from history reports. DV still applies.

EstiVerify shows how much value you lost even with good repairs.

How do I file a diminished value claim

You submit a request to the at fault driver's insurance company with documentation showing your car lost value. They will review and respond.

EstiVerify gives you the documentation you need to support the claim.

Do I need an appraisal to get DV

Sometimes yes, sometimes no. Many insurers require documentation, but not always a formal appraisal.

EstiVerify provides DV documentation that is accepted by many insurers.

How long does a DV claim take

Some are resolved quickly. Others take weeks. It depends on the insurer and how strong your documentation is.

EstiVerify helps you present a clear claim so you can speed up the process.

What do I do if they deny my DV claim

You can ask for a supervisor review, submit stronger documentation, or escalate depending on your state laws.

EstiVerify provides clear reasons to challenge an unfair denial.

How do I get a fair DV payment

You need a solid DV calculation, proof of your car's pre accident value, and evidence of how much value was lost. Insurance must consider reasonable documentation.

EstiVerify gives you a breakdown of your DV amount so you can request a fair payout.

Do Not Leave DV Money On The Table

Insurance companies often underpay diminished value. EstiVerify shows you what your car lost in value and how much the insurer may owe you before you accept anything.

Get In Touch

Address

Office: Cincinnati, OH

Assistance Hours

AI Voice Assistant Available 24/7

Phone Number:

(859) 743-3041

Cincinnati, OH, USA

EstiVerify

Giving vehicle owners their power back in collision repairs.

© 2026 EstiVerify - All Rights Reserved